Art tips Gouache

How to Mix Black Gouache Without Using Black Paint

If you’ve ever run out of black gouache mid-painting—or if you’ve been disappointed by how dull tube black can look—you’re not alone. And the good news? You don’t need black paint to create rich, deep, dramatic blacks in your work.

In this post, I’ll share how to mix your black in gouache using a few color combinations. You’ll get beautiful, velvety blacks with just your regular palette colors, and more importantly—you’ll gain control over how your shadows and dark areas look and feel in your art.

This isn’t just about a workaround. It’s about making your blacks work with your painting instead of flattening it.

Wait… No Black?

Yep. You can absolutely create black without using black paint at all. I rarely reach for tube black in my work unless I need a true black—like when I’m painting a penguin. Otherwise, I find that mixing my black allows me to match the mood and temperature of the painting much better.

And no, I’m not one of those snobby painters who say you should never use black. I do use it sometimes. But when I want my shadows or dark tones to feel alive—to carry warmth, coolness, or richness—I go custom.

Why Not Just Use Black Paint?

Tube black can sometimes kill the life in your painting, especially if you use it straight for shadows. It’s flat and often too harsh next to vibrant colors.

But when you mix your black, you can control the undertones. Perhaps you prefer a warmer black that blends seamlessly into earthy browns or a cooler black that evokes twilight blues. These subtle shifts make your painting more cohesive and more expressive.

And yes, colorful black is totally a thing.

mixing black without black paint

How to Mix Your Own Black

In the video, I demonstrate six different color combinations you can use to mix black gouache. I encourage you to watch it if you want to see how each one looks in real-time, especially with white added to reveal the undertones.

You don’t need to use the exact paints I used—just something close. The idea is to try it out and experiment with what you have. That’s half the fun!

Here’s how I approached it:

Step 1: Swatch Your Starting Blacks

Before I started mixing, I swatched a few standard black paints to get a reference. That way, I could compare them to the mixes and see how close—or different—they were.

Spoiler: Some of the mixes looked better than the tube black.

Step 2: Start Mixing Pairs of Colors

Here’s a general idea of what I mixed (but again—watch the video for the details and visual comparisons):

  • Warm and Cool Pairings: Combining blues and browns often results in beautiful neutrals that lean dark and sophisticated.
  • Complementary Colors: Mixing opposites on the color wheel (like red and green) can cancel each other out, giving you surprisingly deep blacks.
  • Varying the Ratio: Small adjustments in the amount of each color you use can shift the black to appear warmer, cooler, greener, or more purplish. That’s where the control comes in!

One combo came out very green until I adjusted it. Another had an ash-brown undertone. One even leaned toward Payne’s Gray once white was added—perfect for misty shadows.

mixing black without black paint

Step 3: Add White to See the Undertones

On camera, dark paint all looks the same. But in real life, it’s the undertones that matter—and those become clear when you mix in a bit of white.

So, after mixing each black, I added a little white to reveal the hidden hue underneath. That’s where the magic happens. One mix turned blue-gray. Another leaned purple. It helps you see which colors will work best, depending on the mood or lighting in your painting.

This is something I recommend doing with all your custom dark mixes. Just a little white can tell you a lot.

 

Do you want more gouache tips?

Fast, confidence-building shortcuts for colour mixing, brush control & consistent paint texture. Perfect if you’re still fighting “streaky” strokes or muddy mixes.

Get your free 60 gouache tips

 

60 gouache tips

 

 

Step 4: Bonus Mixes and Playing Around

In the end, I threw in a bonus mix with three colors—because why not? Sometimes, blending a warm red, a brown, and a touch of blue can create an earthy, soft black that’s perfect for skin shadows, tree trunks, or anywhere you don’t want a harsh line.

These experimental mixes are where you’ll start to develop your own “signature black.”

mixing black without black paint

Why This Matters for Your Painting

If you’re someone who’s picking up art later in life or just trying to figure out how color works, this kind of mixing gives you confidence. You’re not just copying someone else’s palette—you’re learning how to make your own.

And let’s be honest: It’s deeply satisfying to paint something dark and moody using only colors you’ve mixed yourself. It feels intentional and thoughtful, not like a shortcut.

Try It Yourself

Here’s what I suggest:

  • Pick two dark-ish colors from your palette—maybe a blue and a brown to start.
  • Mix them slowly, adjusting the ratio as needed.
  • Add a touch of white to see what kind of black it is.
  • Label it or swatch it for future use.

Do this a few times, and you’ll start to see what kinds of black feel right in your work.

And if you do try one of these combinations, let me know! I’d love to hear what your favorite is—or what other color mixes you’ve tried. There are so many ways to get to black, and it’s always fun to learn something new.

Similar Posts